RSS Feed

Wednesday Book Review: Proof of Concept


Title: Proof of Concept

Author: Gwyneth Jones

Genre: Sci-fi

Book procurement: Received a copy from for Gamecca Magazine Vol 8 Issue 92.


On a desperately overcrowded future Earth, crippled by climate change, the most unlikely hope is better than none. Governments turn to Big Science to provide them with the dreams that will keep the masses compliant. The Needle is one such dream, an installation where the most abstruse theoretical science is being tested: science that might make human travel to a habitable exoplanet distantly feasible.

When the Needle’s director offers her underground compound as a training base, Kir is thrilled to be invited to join the team, even though she knows it’s only because her brain is host to a quantum artificial intelligence called Altair.

But Altair knows something he can’t tell.

Kir, like all humans, is programmed to ignore future dangers. Between the artificial blocks in his mind, and the blocks evolution has built into his host, how is he going to convince her the sky is falling?


Got permission from my editor to post the Gamecca book reviews here. The reviews in the magazine have a max 200 word count so I’m expanding.

First Thoughts

This novella was really difficult to get in to. You’re thrust suddenly into this sci-fi world, speculating half of what you read hoping it will be cleared later on, with a lot of technical jargon I was swimming through. Although a well written book, it’s definitely not top of my list.


The story is supposed to be about this interaction between Kir and the Artificial Intelligence lodged in her brain given the name Altair, and this back and forth conversation where Altair is warning her of some impending doom and Kir is a stubborn human who ignores it. It’s not. Instead its about why Big Science was used to build a theoretical “ship” called The Needle, which was humanity’s last hope for survivial. It’s about life on The Needle and Kir’s experiences while on it. Here and there Altair makes an appearance but the synopsis is misleading.


The writing is okay. No doubt Gwyneth Jones has some good sci-fi knowledge to make the story the right kind of science to the fiction. An interesting cast of characters overall but I think they existed solely to add some spice to Kir’s life. I was hoping to see more of Altair and get a sense of who/what he was but it’s all hinted. Then the end just started rolling together quickly and then boom it’s over. Like huh?

Final Thoughts

It’s not a bad book, perhaps if it had been expanded more and the relationship between Kir and Altair more solid, perhaps adding a much stronger sense of mystery, Proof of Concept may have been a worthwhile book.

Rating: A meh 2 out of 5


About Nthato Morakabi

Nthato Morakabi is a South African published author. He has short stories appearing in both international and local anthologies, and has published his first book, Beneath the Wax, which opens his three-part novella series "Wax". He is an avid reader, blogger and writer.

8 responses »

  1. That’s a shame because the synopsis seems really good. It always sucks when the synopsis kind of misleads you because you’ve built up an expectation for something. :/

  2. I especially liked the way you offered ways to “fix” the weaknesses you found in the book. This validated your criticisms (which were phrased gently, so I noticed). You have given a fair and honest review.

    • Thanks Rae. I understand the process behind writing, and also considered the fact it was a novella so I can’t be too harsh at all. It’s a great attempt but could have been better. Thank you though.


Any Words to the Writer?

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Rajat Narula

Let's keep the love for books alive

Philosophy is all about being curious, asking basic questions. And it can be fun!

Transmundane Press

Join the Community

Andrew McDowell

An Author of Many Parts

Letters from a Horror Writer

Katie Marie, Horror Enthusiast & Writer

Just another blog of random thoughts.

sakhile whispers

mental health and books over every damn thing

Way Too Fantasy

Speculative fiction book reviews and more!

R. Michael

The home of mysteries, writing, and ponderings.

The Library Ladies

Two librarians, one blog, zero SHH-ing

The Lost Highway Hotel

See cinema differently

Lorraine Ambers

Fantasy writer - Bibliophile - Daydreamer


Ordinary Girl in Love with Horror

SAM's Book Reviews

Books Old & New


Personal blog

%d bloggers like this: